Defending the Christian Faith
  • Home Page
    • About The Author
  • Genesis and Other Books of Bible
    • Blessed Are Those...
    • Jonah
    • Book of Daniel
    • Isaiah the Prophet
    • Psalms
  • Principles of God In Creation
    • Intelligent Design >
      • Animal Societal Structure
      • Uniqueness of Life Forms
      • Comparative Anatomy
    • Issues in Creation and Evolution >
      • Impact of Mutations on Biologic Design >
        • Gene Mutational Load
        • DNA by Design
        • Impact of Flood on DNA Composition
        • Living Fossils, Metamorphosis and Other Anomalies >
          • Transition Life Forms-NO
        • Adaptation/Variation
      • DNA and Structural Homology Studies That Argue Against Evolution >
        • DNA Clocks/Mutations
        • DNA Data Shows Differences Human and Chimpanzee
        • DNA Comparison Among Other Organisms
        • Origin of Life
      • History of Support for Creation Worldview and in Opposition to Evolution Ones
      • Evolutionism and Its Use to Fight Against Christianity
      • Geology and the Flood >
        • Plate Techtonics, Folds and Gaps in Geologic Strata Consistent with The Flood >
          • Worldwide Strata and Uncomformities
          • Formation of Strata on Earth
          • Coal Formation
        • Evidence For Rapid Complete or Partial Fossilization
        • Evidence for a Young Age of the Earth >
          • Ice Cores and C14
          • Radiometric Dating
        • Glossopteris and Other Fossil Evidence for Earth as One Land Mass
        • Evidence for Catastrophic Deposition on earth >
          • Evidence for Catastrophic Excoriation of earth
        • Cambrian Explosion
        • The Geologic Column
        • ICE AGE
    • Irreducible Complexity of Life
    • Metamorphosis
  • God's Creation in Photography 1
    • God's Creation in Photography 2
    • God's Creation in Photography 3
    • God's Glory In Flowers
    • Birds-God's Glory
    • The Heavens Declare the Glory of God
    • Clouds: God's Glory
  • God's Creation in Art
    • God's Creation Revealed In Art con't
  • God's Creation and Scripture
  • The Interfacing of Religion, Philosophy, and Science
    • Education and the Teaching of Science
    • The Triune Nature of Man
    • The Degradation of Secular Man According to Romans 1:19-32
  • Medical and Other Ethics from a Christian Perspective
    • Ethical Status of Human Embryo/Fetal Child >
      • Bible Scriptures Relating to the Sanctity of Human Life
    • Genome Therapy
    • Miscellaneous Medical and Other Ethical Issues
  • Christian Theology and Evangelism
    • Following The Lord >
      • The Ten Commandments
    • Evangelistic Tracts and Bumper Stickers
    • Art Work Demonstrating Biblical Concepts >
      • Ministry of Jesus Christ in Art
    • Bible Translations and Exposition of Genesis
    • The One True God vs False Ones
    • Issues in the Bible >
      • What About Those Who Have Not Heard
      • Who Is Jesus Christ?
      • The Triune Nature of God and man
      • A History of Christian Martyrs
      • Does God Bring Judgement Upon Mankind?
      • Day-Age Controversy
      • When Was Y'shua (Jesus) Born
      • What is the Biblical Def'n of Family
      • New Heavens and Earth
  • Archaeology and Culture of the Middle East
    • Pictures of the Middle East Cultures and Geography
    • Other Middle East Archaeology Sites: Petra
  • Biblical Archaeology
    • Biblical Related Artifacts
    • Ancient Pages of Bible
    • New Testament Related Artifacts and Places >
      • Archaeology-Historic Jesus Christ
      • Roman Leaders in Time of Christ
    • Inter-testamental Period
    • Old Testament Related Artifacts
    • False gods through the Ages
    • Responding to Archaeological Objections to Bible History
  • Geology of Israel and Jordan
  • Bible Sites: Israel and Jordan
    • Israel Sites
    • Jordan Sites
  • Jewish People
    • The Gentiles
  • Anthropological Evidence: Worldwide Flood
    • Noah Flood Stories Worldwide
    • Art Forms found Worldwide
  • Images of Noah's Flood, Others, Bible Pages
    • Scheuchzer 1732
    • Modern Images of Noah and the Ark
    • Jonah
  • Biographies of Christians and Creationists who are scientists
    • Ministers Who Support Genesis
    • Others Who Testify of Faith in Christ
  • Dissertations/Papers of John G Leslie
    • Ancillary Evidence:Noah's Flood
  • Bible Sections As True Narrative Representations
  • The Final Chapter
  • Blog: Defending the Christian Faith
  • Contact Us/Privacy Policy
  • Store:Books and Writings of JGL
  • Links To Other Sites

Comparative Anatomy: Support for a Designer

Comparative Anatomy(and comparative genetics) are advanced as evolutionary proofs today, but they are not. In the past the same physical structures were used by scientists to argue for design (such as William Paley's Natural Theology). The proper use of comparative anatomy should be for observing life forms and their structure/function relationships. This can then be applied to technology: chemical or structural. This is the proper use of science. (See section on the interfacing of religion/philosophy/science.)

It should be noted that I do believe that comparative anatomy is a strong argument for a Creator and argument against evolution but this then begins to involve more assumptions than those used for simple observations of nature. Remember, all scientists are religious and desire to place the observations of science into their worldview. 

Here is an excerpt from William Paley's "The Works of William Paley", 1850, Chapter XII in discussing comparative anatomy: 
"Where we find a general plan pursued, yet with such variation in it as are in each case, requiring the particular exigency of the subject to which it is applied, we possess, in such a plan and such adaptation, the strongest evidence that can be afforded of intellectual design, an wisdom which must completely exclude every other hypothesis..." he then goes on to discuss adaptation "...Of the machines being put together with design, if it were possible to doubt, whilst we saw it only under one mode, and in one form, when we came to observe it in its different application, with such changes of structure, such additions and supplements as the special and particular use in each case demanded, we could not refuse any longer our assent to the proposition 'that intelligence'... had been employed...Very much of the reasoning is applicable to what has been called Comparative Anatomy." 



Picture
Picture

To God Be The Glory